Four People Died in Tesla Model Y Fire in Canada

Tesla Model Y fire in Canada has raised significant concerns about the safety of electric vehicles after four Indian friends tragically died in a fiery accident in Toronto on October 24. The victims—Ketaba Gohil (29), her brother Neelraj (25), Jayrajsingh Sisodia, and Digvijay Patel—were all originally from Gujarat, India.

The incident, which involved a collision that led the Tesla Model Y to burst into flames, has put Tesla’s electronic door design under intense scrutiny, especially since the car’s electronic doors reportedly failed to open.

The accident claimed the lives of four out of five passengers, leaving only one survivor—a young woman in her 20s—who was rescued by Canada Post employee Rick Harper. His heroic actions, which involved smashing a car window to save her, have since sparked a discussion on the importance of accessible escape mechanisms in electric vehicles.

Tesla Model Y Fire in Canada and the Sole Survivor

The fiery accident occurred on October 24 when the Tesla Model Y, carrying five friends, hit a guard rail in Toronto, igniting a blaze that engulfed the vehicle. Tragically, four of the passengers lost their lives in the fire, while only one young woman managed to escape. She owes her life to the quick actions of Rick Harper, a Canada Post employee who witnessed the accident and acted swiftly.

Harper recounted the dramatic rescue, explaining that he grabbed a metal pole to break one of the car’s windows. The survivor managed to escape through the broken window, though Harper initially did not realize that others were still inside the vehicle.

He explained that thick smoke filled the car’s interior, and the woman, clearly distressed, fell out of the car head-first. In his recollection of the rescue, Harper expressed concern over Tesla’s electronic door system, which apparently failed to allow the woman or others to exit the vehicle on their own.

Read : Optimus Robot Serving Drinks, Dancing at Tesla Event: Watch

“I couldn’t open the doors,” Harper noted, adding that the woman had likely tried to open the door herself in desperation. His account has sparked a critical dialogue about the challenges and risks associated with the electronic door mechanisms in Tesla models.

Read : Optimus Robot Could Drive Tesla’s Valuation to $25 Trillion

Tesla’s Safety Design and Concerns Over Electronic Doors

The tragic incident has raised critical questions about the safety design of Tesla’s electronic door system, particularly the reliance on powered buttons instead of conventional door handles. Unlike traditional vehicles, Tesla’s doors open via an electronic button system that requires power.

This design choice can present serious problems during an emergency, especially if the car’s power is compromised, as it often is in crashes. According to Calgary Fire Department Captain Randy Schmitz, the failure of power in a crash can create significant barriers to unlocking doors, especially for occupants who are already in a state of panic.

Tesla Model Y reportedly does have a manual override button, but it is less known to the public and not prominently located, which can make it hard for occupants to find during high-stress situations.

In situations where seconds can mean the difference between life and death, such design features have come under scrutiny, with safety experts and emergency responders questioning the practicality of Tesla’s door mechanisms.

While Tesla advocates have pointed out that the manual override feature does exist, the incident has highlighted the need for clearer public awareness and potentially a more accessible design.

The issue with Tesla’s electronic doors has also been part of ongoing discussions in the United States. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has been investigating similar safety concerns in Tesla vehicles, with nine active cases involving the Model Y for issues like “unexpected brake activation” and “sudden unintended acceleration.”

These incidents, combined with the door design’s reported failure in this Toronto accident, have amplified calls for Tesla to consider revisiting its safety mechanisms to enhance user safety.

Implications for Electric Vehicle Safety

This tragic event has sparked a broader conversation about electric vehicle (EV) safety and the specific design challenges that come with newer technology. EVs, such as the Tesla Model Y, come with advanced, electronically powered features designed to make vehicles more user-friendly.

However, in certain circumstances, these features can become life-threatening hazards. Traditional vehicle doors with manual handles, while seen as outdated by some, provide a straightforward and reliable means of escape during an emergency, while EVs rely on electrical power, which can fail or be hard to use in critical moments.

The implications of this accident go beyond Tesla and speak to the broader EV industry. Electric vehicle manufacturers must address the unique risks of electronic systems, particularly in life-threatening situations like fires or crashes.

Enhanced public education on using emergency release mechanisms, clearer in-car signage for emergency overrides, and the inclusion of manual door options could significantly improve passenger safety.

Experts are also calling for stricter regulatory measures for EVs, with a focus on developing standards that ensure all safety mechanisms function effectively without reliance on vehicle power.

The conversation around EV safety is expected to grow as electric vehicles become more common on the roads. With more consumers choosing EVs for environmental benefits, automakers are responsible for addressing and prioritizing passenger safety.

The tragic accident in Canada serves as a somber reminder of the challenges and responsibilities the EV industry faces in making vehicles safe for all passengers under any circumstance.