A series of human mistakes led to the first loss of New Zealand naval vessel since World War Two. In a tragic incident off the coast of Samoa, the New Zealand Navy suffered a significant loss when the HMNZS Manawanui sank after striking a reef in October.
The cause, as a detailed military court of inquiry has revealed, was not a single technical failure but a series of preventable human errors. This unfortunate event underscores the critical importance of operational protocols and the devastating impact that lapses in procedure can have.
The ship, which was carrying 950 tonnes of diesel, also posed environmental risks as oil leaks into the surrounding waters were a major concern. Thankfully, all 75 crew members were safely evacuated, but the incident has left the navy and the nation grappling with the implications of such a profound operational failure.
The Sequence of Errors
The inquiry into the incident revealed that the primary cause of the sinking was the failure to disengage the ship’s autopilot. The HMNZS Manawanui was conducting a survey mission when it struck a reef, and the crew initially misinterpreted the vessel’s failure to respond to commands as a thruster control issue.
Rear Admiral Garin Golding explained that the crew mistakenly believed they had switched to manual control, leading to the vessel continuing on a dangerous trajectory.
Read : Once Again, New Zealand’s Youngest MP Leads Traditional Māori Dance in Parliament: Watch
When operating in sensitive or hazardous waters, such as the coastal regions near Samoa, disengaging autopilot is a standard procedure. The court found that the crew did not verify whether the ship had switched from autopilot to manual control, a fundamental oversight that ultimately led to the grounding.
Read : New Zealand Removes Burp Tax on Livestock After Backlash from Farmers
“Muscle memory from the person in control should have leaned over to that panel and checked whether the screen said autopilot or not,” Golding stated. This lapse in procedure points to a concerning lack of situational awareness and adherence to established protocols.
The Aftermath and Environmental Concerns
The immediate aftermath of the accident saw the safe evacuation of all 75 crew members aboard the vessel. However, the ship, laden with 950 tonnes of diesel, began to leak fuel into the surrounding waters.
Divers have since been deployed to monitor the leakage, and salvage operations are underway to recover the remaining fuel from the wreckage.
Although no major leaks have been reported so far, the potential for environmental damage remains a significant concern, particularly for the nearby coastal villages that depend on the sea for their livelihoods.
The slow leak has heightened fears of an ecological disaster, prompting swift action from both the navy and environmental agencies. The incident has underscored the vulnerability of fragile marine ecosystems and the dire consequences of naval accidents in such regions.
Efforts to mitigate the environmental impact are ongoing, and the navy has assured the public that every measure is being taken to minimize the damage.
Institutional Responsibility and Future Implications
The loss of the HMNZS Manawanui is the first time New Zealand has lost a naval ship since World War Two, marking a somber moment in the country’s maritime history.
Rear Admiral Golding took responsibility for the incident, acknowledging the need to rebuild public trust in the navy’s operational capabilities. “It is on me, as the Chief of Navy, to earn back your trust,” he stated, highlighting the broader implications for the navy’s reputation and operational integrity.
The inquiry into the incident is expected to conclude next year, after which a separate disciplinary process involving three unnamed crew members will commence.
This process will likely focus on accountability and ensuring that lessons are learned from this tragic event. The navy has already indicated that procedural changes will be made to prevent similar incidents in the future, including more rigorous checks and enhanced training for crew members.
This incident serves as a stark reminder of the importance of vigilance and adherence to protocol, particularly in high-stakes environments such as naval operations.
The sinking of the HMNZS Manawanui has exposed critical vulnerabilities within the navy’s operational procedures, and the response to this tragedy will be closely watched as the inquiry progresses.
let’s enjoy few years on earth with peace and happiness….✍🏼🙏