Amber Heard’s recent Mother’s Day announcement took social media by storm. Sharing a heartfelt message alongside an image of her newborn twins’ feet, she introduced her new daughter, Agnes, and son, Ocean, to the world.
The post was filled with joy and pride as she declared the completion of her family, highlighting the emotional and physical journey she had undertaken to become a mother.
But amid the congratulations and admiration, a single question has dominated online discussions: Who is the father of these children? With Amber stating she became a mother “on her own terms” and alluding to past fertility struggles, attention quickly turned toward one name—Elon Musk.
Musk and Heard’s past relationship has been well-documented. Their romantic entanglement between 2016 and 2018 was the subject of intense public scrutiny. Yet, what’s drawn renewed attention is their alleged legal battle over frozen embryos—biological materials that could now be central to the mystery surrounding the paternity of Heard’s twins.
Though neither Musk nor Heard has publicly confirmed these details, mounting evidence and court-adjacent testimonies suggest that the story may be more than just celebrity gossip.
A Complicated Past: Love, Legal Battles, and Frozen Embryos
The pair’s relationship wasn’t just another Hollywood romance—it was, reportedly, a serious bond with long-term family planning. According to court declarations revealed during the highly publicized defamation trial involving Johnny Depp and Amber Heard, Heard and Musk once agreed to freeze embryos for future use.
This claim was backed by a declaration from Heard’s sister, Whitney Henriquez, and a close family friend, Jennifer Howell, both of whom stated that Amber and Elon had intended to have children together.
But once the relationship ended, things got messy. According to Howell, Musk wanted the embryos destroyed, possibly due to the nature of their breakup or a change of heart. Heard, on the other hand, was reportedly committed to having children regardless of their relationship status.
Legal filings and statements from 2022 hinted at a battle over the control of these embryos—biological entities created using both their genetic material. The details of the legal proceedings were kept private, and no official verdict was made public.
Read : Elon Musk to Step Back from DOGE After Tesla Net Income Fell 71 Percent in the First Quarter
However, multiple reports from credible media sources, including the Daily Mail, suggested that the matter was more than speculative—it was a legal issue taken seriously by both parties. This history of legal disagreement over frozen embryos is why many netizens and observers are now linking Musk to the birth of Heard’s twins.
In forums like Reddit, users have pointed out the biological and legal implications of using embryos, arguing that embryos imply a contribution from both a sperm and egg donor—indicating Elon Musk could indeed be the biological father.
Some even cited unconfirmed rumors that Musk had legally relinquished his parental rights, allowing Heard to use the embryos without his involvement in the children’s lives.
Motherhood On Her Own Terms: What Amber Said and Didn’t Say
In her Instagram post, Amber Heard emphasized her independence and resilience in becoming a mother. She wrote, “Becoming a mother by myself and on my own terms, despite my own fertility challenges, has been the most humbling experience of my life.” The phrasing, while empowering, left room for interpretation.
Did “by myself” mean she used a sperm donor, or was she referring to raising the children alone, regardless of who the biological father might be? She also described Agnes and Ocean as the completion of a family she has long envisioned.
As Heard already has a daughter, Oonagh Paige, who was born via surrogate in 2021, it appears she has pursued motherhood through unconventional and possibly legally complex avenues. It’s important to note that Heard has never revealed the identity of Oonagh’s biological father either, prompting speculation that she has maintained a deliberate silence about the paternal identities of her children.
The lack of transparency, while understandable given her public controversies and desire for privacy, has only fueled curiosity. Many fans and critics alike wonder if her refusal to name the father is a legal necessity tied to a court ruling, or a personal choice aimed at shielding her children from public scrutiny. Either way, it seems clear that Amber is fiercely protective of her motherhood journey and is determined to frame it on her own narrative terms.
Public Speculation and Musk’s Silence
Elon Musk, known for his openness on platforms like X (formerly Twitter), has remained notably silent on the topic. Given his usual readiness to comment on everything from space exploration to meme culture, his silence regarding the twins has raised eyebrows.
Musk is already a father to multiple children from previous relationships, including twins and triplets with his ex-wife Justine Musk, and two children with singer Grimes. The idea that he might father two more children is not far-fetched—but the lack of acknowledgment is.
Still, Musk’s past legal entanglements with Heard over embryos provide a compelling reason for his silence. If there was a legal agreement that permitted Heard to use the embryos without his involvement—possibly including clauses about confidentiality or parental rights—it would explain his decision to stay out of the public conversation.
Some Reddit users even speculated that he legally won the right to not be involved, while Heard retained the right to use the embryos to expand her family. There’s also the public relations angle to consider.
Musk, despite his penchant for headlines, may prefer to avoid reigniting speculation about his past relationship with Heard, particularly given her controversial history with Johnny Depp and the media circus that surrounded their courtroom battle. Associating himself with another potentially volatile narrative might not align with his current public persona, especially as he balances business ventures and an already large family.
Science, Ethics, and the Question of Parenthood
At the center of this unfolding story is a broader question about reproductive technology and modern parenthood. The freezing of embryos, once a medical marvel, has become more common among celebrities and those facing fertility challenges. However, legal and ethical questions still arise, especially when relationships end and agreements over biological material fall into dispute.
If Amber Heard did, in fact, use embryos she and Elon Musk created together, then biologically, Musk would be the father. Yet, depending on the legal outcome of their past court battle, he may have no parental rights or obligations. This scenario underscores how biological parenthood and legal parenthood are no longer automatically intertwined in the modern world.
Heard’s assertion that she is raising the twins alone suggests that even if Musk is the biological father, he may have no role in their upbringing. This could be by choice, by legal arrangement, or both. It also illustrates a new era in which women can, through science and law, assert autonomy over family-building in ways that were unthinkable just decades ago.
As of now, there is no official confirmation from either Amber Heard or Elon Musk about the biological origins of twins Agnes and Ocean. What we do know is that the two shared a serious relationship, made plans to have children, froze embryos, and later clashed over their fate. Amber has since welcomed twins and chosen not to name the father publicly. Elon, meanwhile, remains silent.
Given the available information, many are inclined to believe that Elon Musk could be the biological father—especially in light of the legal battle involving embryos. But unless one of them chooses to confirm or deny it outright, the mystery will likely remain unsolved in the public eye.
In the meantime, Heard seems content with her role as a mother of three, sharing her joy and pride with the world while keeping certain details close to her chest. Whether Musk is part of that story or not, it’s clear she is committed to raising her children independently, on her own terms, and according to a future she once envisioned—regardless of the past.