For decades, the Mystery of Stained-Glass Window Fragments surrounding Dunfermline Abbey in Scotland puzzled historians, congregants, and local authorities. The unexpected arrival of an anonymous package containing 49 stained-glass shards in November 2020 reignited interest in the case.
The fragments, taken from the church decades ago, were finally traced back to their original place, solving a long-standing enigma. Thanks to expert analysis, the historical and artistic significance of these pieces has been uncovered, shedding light on the heritage of the 950-year-old abbey and its celebrated stained-glass windows.
The Arrival of an Anonymous Package and the Mystery of the Glass
The Mystery of Stained-Glass Window Fragments began when Reverend Dr. MaryAnn Rennie of Dunfermline Abbey received a peculiar package addressed to “Bob Brewse”—a fictitious name believed to reference King Robert the Bruce, whose remains are interred at the church.
Inside, wrapped in a 2005 edition of the Fife and Kinross Extra newspaper, were 49 stained-glass fragments, accompanied by a typewritten note. The anonymous sender, identifying themselves only as “CEEPS,” confessed to having taken the glass near scaffolding two decades earlier. They expressed regret for removing the shards and hoped they would be put to good use.
Read : Russia Arrests Two Church Figures Over Alleged Ukrainian Plot to Kill Tikhon Shevkunov
CEEPS’s message read: “I wrapped it up in paper to protect it but never had the chance to return it. Unsure if it was new glass going in or old coming out. I felt a bit guilty taking it and hope it will get used. Regards, CEEPS.”
Read : Church of England Faces Threat of Split Over Stance on Gay Couples
Despite appeals on social media and local outreach efforts, the church was unable to determine which of its ten intact stained-glass windows the pieces belonged to. The fragments, while undoubtedly old, did not immediately match any known designs, leaving the congregation and historians perplexed.
Expert Analysis and Identification of the Margaret Window
Seeking answers, Reverend Dr. Rennie turned to Professor Michael Penman of the University of Stirling. In 2023, Professor Penman delved into old Kirk Session records from the early 1980s, analyzing past damages and repairs to the abbey’s stained-glass windows. He found no direct evidence of a reported loss matching the fragments but suspected they might belong to a historically significant window.
To confirm his hypothesis, he enlisted the help of Dr. Craig Kennedy from the Institute for Sustainable Building Design at Heriot-Watt University.
Dr. Kennedy conducted in-depth scientific tests using electron microscopy and x-ray fluorescence to analyze the chemical composition of the glass. The presence of lead, potassium, arsenic, and sulphur indicated that the fragments had been manufactured between the 1870s and the 1930s.
Further insight came from stained-glass conservator Vivienne Kelly, a PhD student at Heriot-Watt University. Specializing in 19th and 20th-century glass, Ms. Kelly carefully examined four larger pieces to identify their artistic details.
She determined that the fragments depicted elements such as an angel’s wing, the hem of a noble’s robe with intricate knotwork, an angel’s hair, and a thistle motif.
Upon visiting the Abbey Church, Ms. Kelly noted discrepancies in color and texture in one of the windows—the Margaret Window. Installed in 1932, this window depicted the 1070 marriage of Queen Margaret and King Malcolm Canmore.
Ms. Kelly’s expertise allowed her to confirm that the fragments once belonged to this window, and she speculated that the glass was likely damaged by a scaffolding pole during refurbishment work in the late 1990s.
The Historical Significance and Future of the Stained-Glass Fragments
The confirmation that the stained-glass fragments belonged to the Margaret Window provided a significant breakthrough in preserving the historical integrity of Dunfermline Abbey. The window, designed by Alexander Strachan, remains an essential part of the abbey’s rich history, symbolizing Queen Margaret’s enduring influence on Scottish culture and religion.
Despite the resolution of the mystery, questions still linger about CEEPS’s identity and motives. Why did they wait so long to return the glass? What led them to do so in 2020? While the full circumstances remain unknown, their actions ultimately helped restore a vital piece of Scottish heritage.
The fragments will now be displayed at an exhibition at Dunfermline Carnegie Library and Galleries from March 22 to April 6. This showcase will explore the history of the Abbey Church and its role in the local community.
Meanwhile, the church continues its efforts to secure funding for critical repairs. Facing a staggering £8 million bill—£4 million for structural work and another £4 million for facility upgrades—the Abbey Church has launched a fundraising appeal to ensure its continued preservation.
Dr. Rennie expressed gratitude for the resolution of the stained-glass mystery, stating: “We are delighted that the mystery of where this glass originally came from has finally been unravelled. We still have no idea who CEEPS is and why they decided to return it to the abbey when they did, but we are grateful.”
The resolution of this long-standing mystery not only adds to the storied past of Dunfermline Abbey but also highlights the importance of preserving historical artifacts. Whether or not CEEPS ever steps forward, their actions have ensured that the Margaret Window’s lost fragments are no longer a mystery but a celebrated part of Scottish history once more.
let’s enjoy few years on earth with peace and happiness….✍🏼🙏