The tragic death of 10-year-old Khyalmat Khan in northern Pakistan has sent shockwaves through the community and raised urgent questions about corporal punishment in schools. The young boy’s life was cut short after being brutally beaten by his headmaster during a school assembly—a punishment meted out publicly for a minor mistake. This incident not only highlights the dangers of physical discipline but also underscores the ongoing challenges Pakistan faces in protecting children from violence in educational institutions.
The Incident: A Tragic Example of Abuse of Authority
Khyalmat Khan, a Year 6 student, was singled out during an assembly in a private school in the Jamrud area of the Khyber tribal district. Reports reveal that headmaster Waqar Ahmed repeatedly struck Khyalmat with a rod on his head, face, and back. Witnesses say the punishment was for a trivial error, yet the severity of the beating was extreme and merciless, taking place in front of Khyalmat’s classmates and teachers.
Despite being rushed to the hospital, Khyalmat succumbed to his injuries just a few hours later. The headmaster was promptly arrested, and an official investigation was launched into the boy’s death. This horrific event exposed a grim reality: despite the legal ban on corporal punishment in Pakistan, physical violence against children in schools remains a pressing issue.
Corporal punishment was outlawed in Pakistan in 2021 following a series of high-profile cases where children were harmed or even killed due to excessive beatings at schools and other settings. Yet, as this case reveals, the law alone has not been sufficient to eradicate such practices.
Read : Janot-Curie High School Teacher Suspended for Holding Minute’s Silence for Gaza Victims
Authorities have condemned the incident strongly. Khyber District Police Officer Rai Mazhar Iqbal emphasized that violence against children and women will never be tolerated. He called attention to the betrayal of trust involved when a teacher, who should be a guardian and mentor, becomes a perpetrator of cruelty. The gravity of this breach of trust is at the heart of the outrage sparked by this tragedy.
Corporal Punishment in Pakistan: Legal Ban vs. Reality
Corporal punishment in schools was officially banned in Pakistan four years ago, yet it continues covertly in many institutions. The persistence of such violence reflects deeper social and systemic issues. Many children still face physical discipline as a common form of punishment for mistakes, whether minor or major, and the fear of abuse discourages many from attending school.
Read : Acharya Prashant: The Most Followed Spiritual Leader Globally on YouTube
Pakistan is home to one of the largest populations of out-of-school children in the world — estimated to be around 24 million. A significant number of these children cite fear of physical punishment at school as a primary reason for dropping out. This fear is compounded by weak enforcement of laws designed to protect children and a cultural acceptance of corporal punishment as a disciplinary measure.
Campaigners and child rights advocates have repeatedly called for more comprehensive measures beyond legislation. Former lawmaker Mehnaz Akber Aziz stressed that laws alone cannot end corporal punishment. She has advocated for public education campaigns, teacher training, and accessible child helplines to protect children from abuse. Her view is that schools should be places of hope and opportunity, not fear and suffering, and that eradicating physical punishment is essential for tackling broader issues of illiteracy and poverty.
The continued use of corporal punishment despite its prohibition signals a gap between law and practice. The Khyalmat Khan case tragically illustrates what can happen when that gap goes unaddressed — with devastating consequences for innocent children.
Broader Context: Patterns of Violence Against Children in Pakistan
Khyalmat’s death is sadly not an isolated case in Pakistan. Similar tragedies have occurred in recent years, reflecting a persistent problem with violence against children in homes, schools, and workplaces.
In 2021, an eight-year-old boy died in Punjab after allegedly being beaten by his teacher for failing to memorize a lesson. In the capital city of Islamabad in 2020, an eight-year-old girl working as a maid was beaten to death by the family she served after she accidentally let their pet parrots escape. These incidents reveal a pattern of vulnerable children suffering fatal abuse at the hands of adults who wield power over them.
Such cases have sparked national and international condemnation, but they also demand urgent and practical responses. Protection of children from abuse requires not only laws but also cultural change and enforcement. Educating teachers, parents, and communities about the harmful effects of corporal punishment is critical. Children must be seen as rights holders with dignity and deserving of safe, nurturing environments.
The government and civil society must work hand-in-hand to build effective monitoring mechanisms, provide support services for abused children, and prosecute offenders with appropriate severity. Without these steps, stories like Khyalmat’s will continue to surface, underscoring a failure to safeguard the most vulnerable.
The death of Khyalmat Khan is a heartbreaking reminder of the ongoing risks children face in Pakistan’s schools. It exposes the tragic consequences of physical punishment and the urgent need for stronger action to protect children from violence. While laws banning corporal punishment are a crucial step, they must be backed by rigorous enforcement, education, and a cultural shift away from violence as discipline.
Schools should be safe havens where children can learn and grow without fear of harm. The educational system, the community, and the government must unite to ensure that no child suffers as Khyalmat did. Only then can Pakistan truly honor the rights and dignity of its children and create a future where such tragedies are prevented.